Penn Undergraduate Law Journal
  • Home
  • About
    • Mission
    • Masthead
    • Faculty Advisory Board
    • Partner Journals
    • Sponsors
  • Submissions
  • Full Issues
  • The Roundtable
    • Pre-Law Corner
  • Events
  • Contact
    • Contact
    • Apply
    • FAQs
  • Home
  • About
    • Mission
    • Masthead
    • Faculty Advisory Board
    • Partner Journals
    • Sponsors
  • Submissions
  • Full Issues
  • The Roundtable
    • Pre-Law Corner
  • Events
  • Contact
    • Contact
    • Apply
    • FAQs

The Roundtable


Welcome to the Roundtable, a forum for incisive commentary and analysis
on cases and developments in law and the legal system.


INTERESTED IN wRITING FOR tHE rOUNDTABLE?

Comparing Peshat to Constitutional Originalism

3/24/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture
By Rebecca Heilweil

Rebecca Heilweil is a freshman at the University of Pennsylvania.

Religion and legal doctrine have a long, shared history. Before church and state began to move apart, moral ecclesiastic authority and legal force held equal importance.  Canon law was often written within civil code, citing Biblical verses. But more than simply providing another source of statutes, Abrahamic religion underlied the meaning and authority of political compacts.  The Mayflower Compact, for instance, considered America's first constitution, recognizes God, and creates a parallel between the famous biblical covenant and its own political doctrine.

Most early colonial legal documents, perhaps saving Roger William's, which celebrated the non-denominational nature of Rhode Island, embraced Christian rhetoric. References to the Holy Trinity and Jesus Christ were abundant. However, when comparing methods of interpreting religious and legal documents, it is interesting to note the similarities between how rabbinic scholars discuss the Jewish Torah and the Supreme Court analyzes the Constitution.
For as long as humans have considered our relationship with faith, we have struggled to understand and standardize how we interpret rules and the words that construct them. The Torah has its own version of textualism, for instance, and forces rabbis to debate what Hebrew phrases ought to mean. Thus, the popular notion of a separate church and state is challenged through an alternate lens. Our methods for understanding the doctrines of both institutions are surprisingly analogous. This is most clearly demonstrated by a comparison of originalism, a conservative judicial method for American statutes, and Peshat, a theory of rabbinic interpretation.

The Dartmouth Law Journal describes originalism as "the view that the interpretive obligation is to discern and apply the Constitution’s original meaning to current cases." [1] Originalism is one of the more conservative judicial interpretive methods, often resulting in decisions that align with Republican Party lines. The doctrine's proponents on the current court are Associate Justices Clarence Thomas-- known for his quietude-- and Antonin Scalia, famous for his humorous and eloquent writing.

Justice Scalia's originalism centers upon the idea of "original meaning.” He believes that courts should be applying the Constitution's words just as they meant to the Founders at the time of the document’s writing. Scalia fears that involving more than the pure meaning of a statute will invite judicial activism, writing that "the main danger in judicial interpretation of the Constitution -- or, for that matter, in judicial interpretation of any law-- is that the judges will mistake their own predilections for the law." [2]

In short, Scalia worries reading past statutory text will inflate judicial power and overpower democratic processes, putting justices in charge instead of the people. It is perhaps for the same reasons that rabbis support Peshat interpretation. Chabad.org describes Peshat as the "simple interpretation of the Torah. When the verse says (Genesis 1:1) that "In the beginning G-d created the Heaven and Earth," it means exactly what it seems to mean, in a very literal sense." [3] Alternatively, the method of interpretation suffers from the same critiques as originalism. Skeptics worry that meaning cannot simply be derived "literally" and offer that an interpretative method attached to a time period prevents a more modern and fluid religious understanding. Stephen Garfinkel, in his piece "Applied Peshat: Historical-Critical Method and Religious Meaning" writes that "literalism...is not a more 'accurate' understanding of the biblical text and may be a distortion of it as often as not." [4]

Another definition of Peshat seems to more easily match the originalism of Justice Thomas, who seems to care more about public understanding at the time of a statute's writing, not simply the original meaning to the Founding Fathers. "What distinguishes original meaning originalism,” offers Professor Lee J. Strang of the University of Toledo, “Is the sources from which it draws meaning: dictionaries of the era and other founding-era documents. However, since original-meaning originalism’s goal is the text’s original public meaning, the universe of available data includes all evidence of contemporary conventional usage." [5] And, similarly, according to the Jewish Virtual Library, Peshat can be, "the usual accepted traditional meaning as it was generally taught" [6] This conception of Peshat also has more public, general form, just like Thomas's originalism.

The question remains of whether looking to an original meaning or definition is an important task. Other theories of both biblical and statutory interpretation prefer less historically constrained doctrines. Loose constructionists favor laws and rules that can "stretch more." They wonder why we care so much about the past.

But Justice Scalia does not think that question requires an answer. He will jovially retort: “My burden is not to show that originalism is perfect, but that it beats the other alternatives, and that, believe me, is not difficult.”  

[1] Kiran Iyer, "Justice Scalia, Justice Thomas, and Fidelity to Original Meaning," The Dartmouth Law Journal (Spring, 2014).
[2]Ralph A. Rossum, "The Textualist Jurisprudence of Justice Scalia," Claremont McKenna College, http://www.claremontmckenna.edu/salvatori/publications/RARScalia.asp.
[3] Naftali Silberberg, "How is the Torah Interpreted?" http://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/819698/jewish/How-Is-the-Torah-Interpreted.htm
[4] Stephen Garflinkel, "Applied Peshat: Historical-Critical Method and Religious Meaning,” Jewish Theological Seminary of America (1993).
[5] Lee J. Strang, "The Jurisprudence of Constitutional Restoration is Original, but Not All Conceptions of Originalism," Library of Liberty and Law (April 10, 2014).
[6] Louis Isaac Rabinowitz, "Peshat," Jewish Virtual Library, http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/judaica/ejud_0002_0016_0_15649.html (2008).
Photo credit: Flickr user Laurie Cate

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.


    Categories

    All
    Akshita Tiwary
    Alana Bess
    Alana Mattei
    Albert Manfredi
    Alexander Saeedy
    Alexandra Aaron
    Alexandra Kanan
    Alice Giannini
    Alicia Augustin
    Alicia Kysar
    Ally Kalishman
    Ally Margolis
    Alya Abbassian
    Anika Prakash
    Anna Schwartz
    Ashley Kim
    Astha Pandey
    Audrey Pan
    Benjamin Ng'aru
    Brónach Rafferty
    Bryce Klehm
    Cary Holley
    Christina Gunzenhauser
    Christine Mitchell
    Christopher Brown
    Clarissa Alvarez
    Cole Borlee
    Connor Gallagher
    Dan Spinelli
    Dan Zhang
    David Katz
    Davis Berlind
    Derek Willie
    Dhilan Lavu
    Edgar Palomino
    Edna Simbi
    Ella Sohn
    Emma Davies
    Esther Lee
    Evelyn Bond
    Filzah Belal
    Frank Geng
    Gabriel Maliha
    Georgia Ray
    Graham Reynolds
    Habib Olapade
    Hailie Goldsmith
    Haley Son
    Harshit Rai
    Henry Lininger
    Hetal Doshi
    Iris Zhang
    Irtaza Ali
    Isabela Baghdady
    Ishita Chakrabarty
    Jack Burgess
    Jessica "Lulu" Lipman
    Joe Anderson
    Jonathan Lahdo
    Jonathan Stahl
    Joseph Squillaro
    Justin Yang
    Kaitlyn Rentala
    Kanishka Bhukya
    Katie Kaufman
    Kelly Liang
    Keshav Sharma
    Ketaki Gujar
    Lauren Pak
    Lavi Ben Dor
    Libby Rozbruch
    Lindsey Li
    Luis Bravo
    Lyndsey Reeve
    Madeline Decker
    Maja Cvjetanovic
    Maliha Farrooz
    Marco DiLeonardo
    Margaret Lu
    Matthew Caulfield
    Michael Keshmiri
    Mina Nur Basmaci
    Muskan Mumtaz
    Natalie Peelish
    Natasha Darlington
    Natasha Kang
    Nayeon Kim
    Nicholas Parsons
    Nicholas Williams
    Nicole Greenstein
    Nihal Sahu
    Omar Khoury
    Owen Voutsinas Klose
    Owen Voutsinas-Klose
    Pheby Liu
    Rachel Bina
    Rachel Gu
    Rachel Pomerantz
    Rebecca Heilweil
    Regina Salmons
    Sajan Srivastava
    Sandeep Suresh
    Sanjay Dureseti
    Sarah Simon
    Saranya Das Sharma
    Saranya Sharma
    Sasha Bryski
    Saxon Bryant
    Sean Foley
    Sebastian Bates
    Serena Camici
    Shahana Banerjee
    Shannon Alvino
    Shiven Sharma
    Siddarth Sethi
    Sneha Parthasarathy
    Sneha Sharma
    Sophie Lovering
    Steven Jacobson
    Suaida Firoze
    Suprateek Neogi
    Takane Shoji
    Tanner Bowen
    Taryn MacKinney
    Thomas Cribbins
    Todd Costa
    Tyler Larkworthy
    Vatsal Patel
    Vikram Balasubramanian
    Vishwajeet Deshmukh
    Wajeeha Ahmad
    Yeonhwa Lee

    Archives

    March 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    September 2022
    June 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013

Picture
Picture
​