Penn Undergraduate Law Journal
  • Home
  • About
    • Mission
    • Masthead
    • Faculty Advisory Board
    • Partner Journals
    • Sponsors
  • Submissions
  • Full Issues
  • The Roundtable
    • Pre-Law Corner
  • Events
  • Contact
    • Contact
    • Apply
    • FAQs
  • Home
  • About
    • Mission
    • Masthead
    • Faculty Advisory Board
    • Partner Journals
    • Sponsors
  • Submissions
  • Full Issues
  • The Roundtable
    • Pre-Law Corner
  • Events
  • Contact
    • Contact
    • Apply
    • FAQs

The Roundtable


Welcome to the Roundtable, a forum for incisive commentary and analysis
on cases and developments in law and the legal system.


Samantar: Questions of Immunity and Human Rights Remain

3/20/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture
By Natasha Kang
Natasha Kang is a senior at the University of California, Davis.

Few issues can be considered black-and-white with a clear, absolute answer – except violations of human rights, right? Even the overriding international norms of jus cogens do not allow for human rights abuses such as torture and arbitrary imprisonment. [1] However, this is not simple in practice, as seen in the recent history of the case against Mohamed Ali Samantar, a government official under the brutal regime of the late dictator of Somalia, Mohammed Siad Barre. [2] Serving as Defense Minister and later as Prime Minister during the regime, Samantar oversaw armed forces that engaged in acts of torture, rape, abduction, extrajudicial killings, and groundless imprisonment. After moving to the US in 1997, Samantar recently filed his third petition for writ of certiorari in a long battle against the members of the Isaaq clan, victims of Samantar’s actions while he was working under the regime. [2] 

In 2004, the Center for Justice & Accountability (CJA) filed a complaint with the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia. [3] Samantar was charged for the “extrajudicial killing; arbitrary detention; torture and cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment; crimes against humanity; and war crimes” committed by the armed forces he oversaw. [4] After a struggle to enforce a subpoena in order to obtain documents concerning human rights and military issues in Somalia, Samantar’s motion to dismiss was granted based on statutory immunity grounds. This meant that under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA) [4], Samantar possessed “immunity from civil lawsuits to foreign states and to their agencies and instrumentalities” because officials acting on orders should be treated as an agency or instrumentality. [5]

An appeal to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals overturned this dismissal on the grounds that the FSIA language does not apply to government officials. Later, although holding that their decision was specific to this case, the Supreme Court confirmed the Fourth Circuit’s ruling that the FSIA did not immunize individual officials in a unanimous 9-0 decision. [6]  

However, this case was far from over. In their decision, the Supreme Court both upheld the decision of the Fourth Circuit and remanded the case for proceedings to the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia. [7] Once again, Samantar filed a motion to dismiss the complaint against him with the argument that he was entitled to “common law immunity” and “head-of-state immunity,” among other reasons. [8] The former allows officials of the state to have immunity in regard to their actions as official, while the latter is a doctrine in international law that allows a head of state to be immune from the jurisdiction of a foreign state’s courts. [9]

In a highly unusual move, the US government intervened in this case with a Statement of Interest stating that Samantar did not have a claim to common law immunity because: (1) the U.S. government did not currently recognize a government of Somalia and (2) permanent residents of the US, including Samantar, were subject to the jurisdiction of U.S. courts. [10] Following this intervention, the court denied the motion to dismiss. After a series of back-and-forth moves between Samantar and the plaintiffs, Samantar accepted liability for $21 million in damages to the plaintiffs. [11] However, the political context of this case was changed when the U.S. government officially recognized the Somali government in January 2013. With this change invalidating an important part of the government’s Statement of Interest, Samantar filed his second petition to the Supreme Court with renewed hope, backed by a coalition including three former U.S. Attorneys General which argued that this exception to jus cogens risked exposing U.S. officials to lawsuits in foreign countries. [12] The CJA filed in opposition, and the Solicitor General filed a brief urging the court to grant the petition and ultimately remand the case for a new ruling on the common law immunity issue due to changed circumstances. The Supreme Court denied certiorari, leaving the Fourth Circuit decision unaltered.

After the Supreme Court’s denial of this petition and the Fourth Circuit’s denial of Samantar’s second appeal, he filed a third petition to be heard by the Supreme Court. This third petition for a writ of certiorari asks again if a foreign official’s common law immunity for “acts performed on behalf of a foreign state” are revoked by the plaintiffs’ claims that those official affects violate jus cogens norms. [13] It will be the final judgment for Samantar—if this petition is denied by the Supreme Court for review, the $21 million judgment will be absolute, and it will remain to be seen whether or not the political aftermath feared by Samantar’s supporters will come to fruition.

[1] Jus Cogens, Cornell University Law School Legal Information Institute, https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/jus_cogens.
[2] Daniel Schulman, “The War Criminal Next Door,” Mother Jones, February 28, 2010, http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2010/02/war-criminal-next-door.
[3] Yousuf v. Samantar, Center for Justice & Accountability, http://www.cja.org/section.php?id=85.
[4] Ibid.
[5] Ibid.
[6] Yousuf v. Samantar, Center for Justice & Accountability
[7] Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, U.S. Department of State – Bureau of Consular Affairs, http://travel.state.gov/content/travel/english/legal-considerations/judicial/service-of-process/foreign-sovereign-immunities-act.html.
[8] Sovereign Immunity, Cornell University Law School Legal Information Institute, https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/sovereign_immunity.
[9] Bashe Abdi Yousuf et al. v. Mohamed Ali Samantar, International Crimes Database, 2013, http://www.internationalcrimesdatabase.org/Case/797.
[10] U.S Statement of Interest, U.S. Department of State, http://www.cja.org/downloads/Samantar_Stmt_of_Interest.pdf.
[11] Yousuf v. Samantar, Center for Justice & Accountability.
[12] Ibid.
[13] Petition regarding Samantar v. Yousuf et. al., http://sblog.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/Samantar-v-Yousuf-Cert-Petition-FINAL.pdf.
Photo credit: Flickr user Africa Renewal


0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.


    Categories

    All
    Aaron Tsui
    Akshita Tiwary
    Alana Bess
    Alana Mattei
    Albert Manfredi
    Alexander Saeedy
    Alexandra Aaron
    Alexandra Kanan
    Alexandra Kerrigan
    Alice Giannini
    Alicia Augustin
    Alicia Kysar
    Ally Kalishman
    Ally Margolis
    Alya Abbassian
    Amanda Damayanti
    Anika Prakash
    Anna Schwartz
    Arshiya Pant
    Ashley Kim
    Astha Pandey
    Audrey Pan
    Benjamin Ng'aru
    Brónach Rafferty
    Bryce Klehm
    Cary Holley
    Catherine Tang
    Christina Gunzenhauser
    Christine Mitchell
    Christopher Brown
    Clarissa Alvarez
    Cole Borlee
    Connor Gallagher
    Dan Spinelli
    Dan Zhang
    David Katz
    Davis Berlind
    Derek Willie
    Dhilan Lavu
    Edgar Palomino
    Edna Simbi
    Ella Jewell
    Ella Sohn
    Emma Davies
    Esther Lee
    Evelyn Bond
    Filzah Belal
    Frank Geng
    Gabrielle Cohen
    Gabriel Maliha
    Georgia Ray
    Graham Reynolds
    Habib Olapade
    Hailie Goldsmith
    Haley Son
    Hannah Steinberg
    Harshit Rai
    Hennessis Umacta
    Henry Lininger
    Hetal Doshi
    Ingrid Holmquist
    Iris Zhang
    Irtaza Ali
    Isabela Baghdady
    Ishita Chakrabarty
    Jack Burgess
    Jessica "Lulu" Lipman
    Joe Anderson
    Jonathan Lahdo
    Jonathan Stahl
    Joseph Squillaro
    Justin Yang
    Kaitlyn Rentala
    Kanishka Bhukya
    Katie Kaufman
    Kelly Liang
    Keshav Sharma
    Ketaki Gujar
    Khlood Awan
    Lauren Pak
    Lavi Ben Dor
    Libby Rozbruch
    Lindsey Li
    Luis Bravo
    Lyan Casamalhuapa
    Lyndsey Reeve
    Madeline Decker
    Maja Cvjetanovic
    Maliha Farrooz
    Marco DiLeonardo
    Margaret Lu
    Matthew Caulfield
    Michael Keshmiri
    Michael Merolla
    Mina Nur Basmaci
    Muskan Mumtaz
    Natalie Peelish
    Natasha Darlington
    Natasha Kang
    Nathan Liu
    Nayeon Kim
    Nicholas Parsons
    Nicholas Williams
    Nicole Greenstein
    Nicole Patel
    Nihal Sahu
    Omar Khoury
    Owen Voutsinas Klose
    Owen Voutsinas-Klose
    Paula Vekker
    Pheby Liu
    Pragat Patel
    Rachel Bina
    Rachel Gu
    Rachel Pomerantz
    Rebecca Heilweil
    Regina Salmons
    Sajan Srivastava
    Samantha Graines
    Sandeep Suresh
    Sanjay Dureseti
    Sarah Simon
    Saranya Das Sharma
    Saranya Sharma
    Sasha Bryski
    Saxon Bryant
    Sean Foley
    Sebastian Bates
    Serena Camici
    Shahana Banerjee
    Shannon Alvino
    Shiven Sharma
    Siddarth Sethi
    Sneha Parthasarathy
    Sneha Sharma
    Sophie Lovering
    Steven Jacobson
    Suaida Firoze
    Suprateek Neogi
    Takane Shoji
    Tanner Bowen
    Taryn MacKinney
    Thomas Cribbins
    Todd Costa
    Tyler Larkworthy
    Tyler Ringhofer
    Vatsal Patel
    Vikram Balasubramanian
    Vishwajeet Deshmukh
    Wajeeha Ahmad
    Yeonhwa Lee

    Archives

    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    September 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    May 2023
    March 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    September 2022
    June 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.